The Christian is not to ask whether this or that event happened because of a prayer. He is rather to believe that all events without exception are answers to prayer in the sense that whether they are grantings or refusals the prayers of all concerned and their needs have all be taken into account. All prayers are heard, thought not all prayers are granted. We must not picture destiny as a film unrolling for the most part on its own, but in which our prayers are sometimes allowed to insert additional items. On the contrary; what the film displays to us as it unrolls already contains the results of our prayers and of all our other acts. There is no question whether an event has happened because of your prayers. When the event you prayed for occurs your prayer has always contributed to it. When the opposite event occurs your prayer has never been ignored; it has been considered and refused, for your ultimate good and the good of the whole universe.

— C.S. Lewis

Cited from “On ‘Special Providences,’” in Miracles (New York: HarperOne,1947, 1974), 293-294.

It is often said that God answers prayers as either “Yes,” “No” or “Wait.” This is profoundly true. What we often dread is the “No.” But Lewis makes a very wise observation in that the “No” is from God’s perspective good for the petitioner and the world itself. Some answers to prayers can have unintended negative consequences.

Clive Staples Lewis (November 29, 1898 – November 22, 1963) was an exceptional scholar, novelist, and Christian apologist from the Anglican tradition. Chronicles of Narnia serves as a fine example of Lewis as a prolific storyteller who captivated the imaginations of multitudes.

A learned scholar with expertise in medieval and Renaissance literature, Lewis also authored numerous fiction and non-fiction works that touched on matters of philosophy and Christian apologetics.

4 thoughts on “C.S. Lewis: There is no question whether an event has happened because of your prayers.

    1. When it comes to the above C.S. Lewis quote, we have the fruit of a mind deeply saturated in biblical truth, which had come about through the careful reading, interpretation, and subsequent theological reflection upon the panoply of the Scriptures. The whole Bible informs Lewis’ point on prayer above.

      If we can take some baby steps in gathering passage for reflection, I think they would include what David sings about on God’s knowledge and sovereignty over our lives from Psalm 139. We have the words of Christ on prayer from Matthew 6:7-13, 7:7-11, 21:22. Then there are NT epistles like James 4:3, 13-16, 5:13-18; 1 John 3:22, 5:14-15.

      Here is a helpful article by Elizabeth Turnage Reynolds on feelings of prayers being unanswered during life struggles: https://www.equip.org/articles/how-unanswered-prayer-grows-faith-hope-and-love/

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment